I have spent hours clearing overgrown branches and cutting firewood in my backyard using both of these corded electric tools. Testing the lightweight Earthwise 9-Amp alongside the more powerful Craftsman 12-Amp showed me exactly where each machine shines. If you want to know which of these yard tools is worth your hard-earned money, my hands-on comparison will help you make the right choice.
9 amp vs 12 amp chainsaw: At a Glance
| 9 amp | 12 amp chainsaw | |
|---|---|---|
| Motor Power | Lower power, suitable for light-duty tasks. | Moderate power, capable of handling tougher cuts. |
| Recommended Bar Length | Typically 10 to 14 inches. | Typically 14 to 16 inches. |
| Ideal Applications | Light pruning, trimming small branches, and basic yard maintenance. | Cutting firewood, clearing medium branches, and storm cleanup. |
| Weight and Maneuverability | Extremely lightweight and easy to handle for extended periods. | Slightly heavier but offers better stability for larger cuts. |
| Cutting Speed | Slower cutting speed on dense or thick wood. | Faster cutting speed and smoother performance through medium logs. |
| Extension Cord Demands | Less demanding; compatible with standard light-to-medium duty cords. | Requires heavier-gauge extension cords to prevent voltage drops. |
| User Fatigue | Minimal physical strain, ideal for beginners or quick tasks. | Moderate physical strain due to increased weight and torque. |
Complete Comparison: 9 amp vs 12 amp chainsaw
| Earthwise CS33114 14 in. 9-Amp Corded | CRAFTSMAN Electric Chainsaw, 16 Inch, 12 | |
|---|---|---|
| Product Image |  |  |
| Price | View On Amazon | View On Amazon |
| Category | Budget / Light-Duty Corded | Mid-Range / Medium-Duty Corded |
| Motor Power | 9-Amp motor | 12-Amp motor |
| Bar & Chain Length | 14-inch bar and chain | 16-inch low kickback bar and chain |
| Weight & Handling | Ultra-lightweight (just over 7 lbs) and compact | Ergonomic design, standard corded weight |
| Chain Tensioning | Standard manual tensioning | Tool-free chain tensioning |
| Safety Features | Integrated chain brake mechanism | Low kickback bar and chain design |
| Oiling System | Automatic bar/chain oiler with built-in reservoir level window | Auto-oiling with built-in oil window (no priming required) |
| Warranty | 2-Year Limited Warranty | 3-Year Limited Warranty |
| Best For | Bushes, shrubs, stumps, light limbs, and users preferring a very lightweight tool | Firewood, tough cuts, larger fallen limbs, and medium-duty yard tasks |
| Amazon Link | View On Amazon | View On Amazon |
| Overall Winner | Runner-up (Best for Light Duty) | Winner (Best Overall Performance) |
Earthwise CS33114 14 in. 9-Amp Corded Electric Chainsaw
I initially picked up the Earthwise CS33114 because I needed something lightweight for quick trimming sessions. This tool features a compact 14-inch bar and chain paired with a reliable 9-Amp motor that handles light yard work surprisingly well. Safety feels solid thanks to the built-in chain brake mechanism. It includes an automatic bar and chain oiler with a handy oil reservoir level window so you can monitor your lubrication at a glance. Weighing in at just over 7 pounds, this eco-friendly machine requires zero gas mixing and creates no smelly exhaust fumes.
- 9-Amp motor provides reliable power for light to medium yard maintenance tasks.
- 14-inch bar and chain offers a compact cutting profile for tight spaces.
- Automatic oiling system keeps the bar lubricated during operation without manual priming.
- Built-in chain brake enhances safety by stopping the chain quickly if kickback occurs.
7-pound lightweight design reduces operator fatigue during extended overhead trimming sessions.
Very easy to maneuver in tight spots and high tree limbs.
- Requires minimal maintenance compared to gas-powered alternatives.
- Transparent oil window makes monitoring fluid levels quick and straightforward.
Budget-friendly price point makes it highly accessible for occasional users.
Struggles with thick logs over 10 inches in diameter.
- Plastic tensioning screw feels a bit delicate under heavy tension.
Best for:
Homeowners with small yards who need a tool for light pruning, clearing small branches, and basic bush maintenance.
Expert Opinion: This model is the perfect choice for anyone who finds heavy chainsaws intimidating, as its featherweight build prioritizes easy control over sheer cutting speed.
CRAFTSMAN Electric Chainsaw, 16 Inch, 12 Amp (CMECS600)
Moving up to the Craftsman CMECS600 immediately changes the cutting dynamic in your backyard. Equipped with a powerful 12-Amp motor, this corded option drives through thicker logs with noticeably more authority. The 16-inch low kickback bar and chain allows you to tackle larger yard projects without stalling. Maintenance is simplified by the tool-free chain tensioning system that lets you adjust the chain tension on the fly with a simple dial. It also features an auto-oiling system with a window to keep your chain running smoothly. Craftsman backs this tool with a 3-year limited warranty for peace of mind.
- 12-Amp motor delivers extra torque for tackling stubborn wood and medium-sized logs.
- 16-inch low kickback bar and chain increases the cutting capacity for larger backyard trees.
- Tool-free chain tensioning allows fast adjustments without carrying separate wrenches.
- Auto-oiling mechanism ensures constant lubrication for smoother cuts and longer bar life.
3-year limited warranty provides long-term protection against manufacturing defects.
Cuts through medium hardwoods significantly faster than lower-amp models.
- Toolless tensioning dial is highly convenient and saves time during jobs.
- Comfortable ergonomic handle reduces vibration in your hands.
Feels sturdy and well-balanced during horizontal cuts.
Heavier build can cause shoulder fatigue faster when trimming overhead branches.
- Chain oil tends to leak slightly during storage if the reservoir is left full.
Best for:
Suburban homeowners who need to cut down small trees, process firewood, or clean up storm damage involving thicker branches.
Expert Opinion: The extra power and tool-free tensioning system make this tool a highly capable utility saw for demanding cleanup tasks around the yard.
9 amp vs 12 amp chainsaw: Key Differences That Matter
Performance comparison
The difference in raw cutting power becomes obvious the moment you press the trigger. While the 9-Amp Earthwise spins the chain fast enough for thin limbs, it bogs down when you press into dense oak or maple. The 12-Amp Craftsman pulls through these tougher materials without pausing. You get 33% more electrical current flow with the larger motor. This translates directly to higher chain torque, meaning you can cut wider logs without worrying about the motor overheating.
Price/Value analysis
Budget plays a major role in this decision. The Earthwise model usually costs less, making it highly attractive if you only pull it out once or twice a year. You pay a bit of a premium for the Craftsman. However, the larger motor, longer bar, and tool-free tensioner offer excellent value for the extra investment. Buying the cheaper model might cost you more in the long run if you burn out the motor trying to cut wood that is too thick.
Build quality comparison
Both chainsaws rely heavily on plastic housings to keep their overall weight down. Earthwise uses lightweight plastics that keep the tool highly agile, though the tensioning mechanism feels somewhat fragile. Craftsman feels a bit more solid in the hands. The tensioning knob on the Craftsman side cover is thick, sturdy, and easy to grip even when you are wearing thick work gloves. The bar clamp feels more secure on the larger saw, which reduces chain throwing during heavy use.
User experience differences
Handling these two saws feels completely different. The Earthwise is incredibly light. You can easily hold it with one hand to trim a high branch, though safety rules advise using both hands. The Craftsman requires a firmer two-handed grip because of the heavier motor and longer bar. Adjusting the chain on the Earthwise requires you to keep a screwdriver nearby. On the other hand, the tool-free dial on the Craftsman allows you to tighten a sagging chain in about ten seconds flat.
Which Should You Choose?
Choosing the right corded electric tool depends entirely on your yard size and physical comfort. If you have limited physical strength or primarily need to trim soft bushes, thin limbs, and decorative trees, the Earthwise 9-Amp model is your best bet. It is cheap, exceptionally light, and very easy to store in a small garage.
If your property has mature trees, storm debris, or a fireplace that requires firewood prep, the Craftsman 12-Amp model is the superior tool. The extra power prevents stalling, and the larger bar lets you cut through thick logs in a single pass. You will appreciate the tool-free tensioning system if you plan to use the machine for hours at a time.
For general homeowners, the Craftsman CMECS600 offers a better balance of capability and convenience. The 12-Amp motor provides the muscle needed for unexpected storm cleanup, and the tool-free tensioner saves you from constant frustration. Unless you strictly need the lightest tool possible for physical reasons, spending a little extra on the 12-Amp saw is the smarter long-term investment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the main performance difference in a 9 amp vs 12 amp chainsaw comparison?
A: The primary difference lies in torque and motor power. A 12-amp motor draws more electricity to maintain chain speed under heavy loads, whereas a 9-amp motor is designed for lighter trimming and can easily stall when cutting thick logs.
Q: Can I use an extension cord with both of these chainsaws?
A: Yes, you must use a heavy-duty outdoor extension cord. For the 12-amp model, you need a 12-gauge cord if you are running it 100 feet to prevent voltage drops. The 9-amp model can safely run on a 14-gauge cord over the same distance.
Q: When deciding between a 9 amp vs 12 amp chainsaw, which one is safer for beginners?
A: The 9-amp chainsaw is often safer for beginners because it is extremely lightweight and easy to control. It has less kickback potential, making it less intimidating for users who have never operated a chainsaw before.
Q: Do these corded electric chainsaws require bar and chain oil?
A: Yes, both models require chain oil to lubricate the bar and prevent friction heat. Always fill the oil reservoir before plugging the tool into an outlet, and monitor the window during use.
Q: Can the 12-Amp Craftsman chainsaw cut down a medium-sized tree?
A: Yes, the 16-inch bar on the Craftsman allows you to cut down small to medium-sized trees up to 14 inches in diameter. You should take your time and let the motor do the work without forcing it.
Q: Why does my Earthwise 9-Amp chainsaw chain keep coming loose?
A: Chains naturally stretch as they heat up during operation. Since the Earthwise model uses a manual tensioning screw, you must check and tighten the chain frequently with a tool to keep it seated in the bar groove.
Q: Are corded chainsaws quieter than gas-powered chainsaws?
A: Both of these corded electric models are significantly quieter than gas engines. They do not emit loud exhaust noise, though you will still hear the high-pitched whine of the electric motor and the chain spinning on the bar.
As an Amazon Associate, We earn from qualifying purchases