I have spent weeks pushing both of these manual mowers across different types of grass to see how they actually perform in a real yard. In this hands-on comparison, you will learn how their blade configurations, cutting widths, and physical weights affect your weekly mowing routine. My goal is to help you decide which of these classic Scotts models fits your specific grass type and physical strength.
scotts reel mower 16 vs 20: At a Glance
| Scotts 16-Inch Reel Mower | Scotts 20-Inch Reel Mower | |
|---|---|---|
| Cutting Width | Narrower 16-inch path, ideal for tight spaces and easier maneuvering | Wider 20-inch path, covers more ground per pass to save time |
| Physical Weight | Lighter weight, making it easier to push, lift, and store | Heavier build, requiring more physical effort to push and maneuver |
| Blade Configuration | Typically features more blades (7-blade) for a finer, closer cut | Typically features fewer blades (5-blade) suited for standard grass heights |
| Best Grass Types | Excellent for dense, low-growing, and fine turf grasses | Better suited for taller, mixed, and everyday residential lawn grasses |
| Maneuverability | Highly agile around obstacles, garden beds, and narrow pathways | Less agile in tight spots, best for wide-open lawn areas |
| Physical Exertion | Lower pushing resistance due to smaller frame and lighter weight | Higher pushing resistance, offering a more strenuous physical workout |
| Storage Footprint | Compact design that takes up minimal space in sheds or garages | Bulkier profile requiring more storage space on the floor or wall |
Complete Comparison: Scotts 16-Inch Reel Mower vs Scotts 20-Inch Reel Mower
| Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 2607-16S 16-Inch | Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 2000-20S 20-Inch | |
|---|---|---|
| Product Image |  |  |
| Price | View On Amazon | View On Amazon |
| Category | Specialty Precision Manual Reel Mower | Classic Standard Manual Reel Mower |
| Cutting Width | 16 inches for tight spaces and easy maneuverability | 20 inches for faster coverage of large areas |
| Reel Blade Count | 7-blade reel (ideal for fine turf like Bermuda, Zoysia, Ryegrass, and Fescue) | 5-blade ball bearing reel (standard for general grass types) |
| Blade Material | Heat-treated alloy steel | Heat-treated alloy steel for staying sharp longer |
| Cutting Height Range | Designed for a clean, low, precise cut on fine turf | Quick-snap 1″ to 3″ height adjustment |
| Handle & Grip | Padded U-handle for comfort and improved control | Ergonomic handle with cushioned grip; tool-less assembly |
| Wheel Configuration | Standard lightweight tracking wheels | 10″ dual tracking wheels for smoother rolling |
| Best For | Small to medium lawns with fine, dense turf grasses | Medium to large lawns needing wider passes and variable heights |
| Amazon Link | View On Amazon | View On Amazon |
| Overall Winner | Runner-up (Best for specialty/fine turf) | Winner (Best for general lawns) |
Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 2607-16S 16-Inch 7-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower
The Scotts 16-Inch 7-Blade mower is a specialized tool designed specifically for homeowners who want a putting-green finish on dense, low-growing turf. When I first lifted this mower, its lightweight construction stood out, making it incredibly easy to lift into a car trunk or hang on a garage wall. The standout feature is the 7-blade reel made from heat-treated alloy steel, which spins rapidly to deliver an exceptionally clean, scissor-like cut. Pushing the mower feels comfortable because the padded U-handle absorbs a lot of the vibration when traversing uneven ground. It excels in tight spaces and on delicate grass varieties that easily bruise under heavy rotary mowers.
- 7-Blade Reel Design: Ideal for fine to medium turf grasses such as Bermuda, zoysia, ryegrass, and fescue.
- 16-Inch Cutting Width: Excellent for navigating tight corners, narrow pathways, and small lawns.
- Padded U-Handle: Provides cushioned comfort and improves steering control during longer sessions.
Tool-Free Assembly: Ready to roll out of the box in minutes without searching for wrenches.
Incredible cutting precision on fine, dense grass types
- Very lightweight and easy to maneuver around flower beds
Requires minimal storage space in small garages or sheds
Struggles with tall weeds and grass over four inches
- Narrower path means more passes on larger lawns
- Harder to push through thick, overgrown turf due to the high blade count
Best For
This mower is best for homeowners with small to medium yards planted with warm-season grasses like Bermuda or zoysia who want a manicured, ultra-clean cut.
Expert Opinion: The seven-blade setup on this machine acts like high-end hair shears, making it the superior choice for low-cut, dense turf grasses.
Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 2000-20S 20-Inch 5-Blade Classic Push Reel Lawn Mower
The Scotts 20-Inch Classic is a beast of a manual mower that aims to replace your gas machine for standard backyard duties. Pushing this wider deck allows you to cover large areas quickly, thanks to the generous 20-inch cutting width that reduces your total walking time. The cutting system relies on a 5-blade ball bearing reel paired with 10-inch dual tracking wheels that roll smoothly over divots and twigs. I appreciate the quick-snap cutting height adjustment which lets you change the height from 1 to 3 inches instantly with a simple lever pull. The blades are made of heat-treated alloy steel for long-lasting sharpness, while the ergonomic handle with cushioned grip keeps your hands comfortable during longer mowing sessions.
- 20-Inch Cutting Width: Reduces mowing time by covering more ground with every single pass.
- Quick-Snap Height Adjustment: Easily adjust the cutting height from 1 to 3 inches with a simple lever.
- 10-Inch Dual Tracking Wheels: Offers superior traction and stability on uneven terrain.
5-Blade Ball Bearing Reel: Designed to cut taller, standard lawn grasses with less physical pushing force.
Wide cutting path finishes the job much faster
- Handles taller grass and common weeds better than the 16-inch model
High maximum height of 3 inches is great for cool-season grasses
Noticeably heavier and harder to turn in tight corners
- Can leave some tall seed heads standing, requiring a second pass
- Requires more physical effort to get moving from a complete stop
Best For
This model is best for suburban homeowners with medium to large yards who want to transition away from gas mowers without spending hours pacing back and forth across the lawn.
Expert Opinion: The five-blade reel combined with a wider cutting deck makes this model the closest manual equivalent to a standard gas mower.
Scotts Reel Mower 16 vs 20: Key Differences That Matter
Understanding the practical differences between the scotts reel mower 16 vs 20 will save you from a lot of frustration on hot summer afternoons.
Performance Comparison
The cutting action of these two mowers is fundamentally different. The 16-inch model features seven blades, while the 20-inch model uses five blades. A seven-blade reel cuts more frequently per foot of forward travel. This means the 16-inch model chops grass into tiny, pristine bits, making it perfect for low, dense lawns. The 20-inch model, with its five blades, leaves more space between cuts. This design allows it to swallow and slice taller, thicker grass blades without jamming. If you let your grass grow a bit too long between weekend cuts, the 20-inch model handles the neglect much better.
Price and Value Analysis
Generally, the 16-inch model comes with a slightly lower price tag. You are paying for a compact, highly specialized tool. The 20-inch model costs a bit more, but it offers a lot more metal, wider wheels, and a more robust height adjustment system. For most average yards, the 20-inch model represents better utility value because it cuts a wider variety of grass heights.
Build Quality Comparison
Both mowers feature high-quality, heat-treated alloy steel blades that stay sharp for years with proper care. However, the frame structures differ. The 20-inch classic model feels more substantial, featuring thick side plates and heavy-duty 10-inch tracking wheels. The 16-inch model feels lighter and utilizes a simpler chassis design. The height adjustment mechanism on the 20-inch model is a joy to use, utilizing a quick-snap lever, whereas the 16-inch model requires a more manual adjustment process.
User Experience Differences
Pushing these mowers reveals their true characters. The 16-inch mower feels like a nimble toy. You can spin it around on a dime, lift it with one hand, and zip through tight garden paths. The 20-inch mower requires some real leg drive to get started. It feels heavy, but once it gains momentum, the large wheels glide over bumps easily. You will sweat more pushing the 20-inch model, but you will finish the chore much sooner because of the wider path.
Which Should You Choose?
Your choice between these two manual mowers depends on your grass type, physical fitness, and yard layout.
If you have a flat, small yard planted with Bermuda, zoysia, or bentgrass, the 16-inch 7-blade model is your best match. This model is also perfect for seniors or anyone who prefers a lightweight, effortless push over speed. It fits easily into tight suburban lots with lots of landscaping beds.
If you have a larger yard with typical cool-season grasses like Kentucky bluegrass, fescue, or ryegrass, the 20-inch 5-blade classic model is the right choice. It is the better option for busy people who might skip a week of mowing and need a machine that can handle taller growth up to three inches.
Ultimately, the Scotts 20-inch mower is the practical workhorse for the average family home. The Scotts 16-inch mower is a precision tool for lawn enthusiasts who love maintaining a short, golf-course finish.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Which model is easier to push, the scotts reel mower 16 vs 20?
A: The 16-inch model is significantly easier to push and maneuver because of its lighter overall weight and narrower frame. However, if your grass is tall, the 20-inch model actually becomes easier to push because its 5-blade system does not clog as easily as the tight 7-blade reel on the 16-inch model.
Q: Can I use the scotts reel mower 16 vs 20 on tall weeds?
A: Neither mower is designed for tall, thick weeds. Reel mowers work by pulling grass blades between a spinning reel and a stationary bedknife. Tall, woody weeds will simply bend forward under both mowers rather than getting cut.
Q: How often do I need to sharpen the blades on these mowers?
A: Under normal yard conditions without rocks or thick twigs, the heat-treated alloy steel blades will stay sharp for three to five years. You can easily extend this by applying a simple lapping compound to the blades once a year to keep the edges crisp.
Q: Do these mowers come with grass catcher attachments?
A: These specific models do not include grass catchers in the box. You can purchase a universal Scotts reel mower grass catcher separately, which attaches to the rear frame of both the 16-inch and 20-inch models.
Q: Can I adjust the cutting height on both models?
A: Yes, both mowers allow you to adjust the cutting height. The 20-inch model features an easy-to-use quick-snap lever that adjusts from 1 to 3 inches. The 16-inch model also adjusts but has a slightly lower cutting range designed for short-cut turf.
Q: Do these mowers handle wet grass well?
A: It is best to avoid mowing wet grass with any reel mower. Wet clippings clump together and stick to the blades, which can cause the reel to jam and result in a chewing motion rather than a clean cut.
As an Amazon Associate, We earn from qualifying purchases